WEEK 5
Tiebout
Again we have an instance of an author working through a set of formalistic models—with explicit assumptions about human behavior/reality—that might seem very off-putting to you as a reader. I know I had a hard time with this piece. At least it’s short.
When you read it, keep in mind this week's assignment: In this theory whom does city government serve? What issues get considered, and who, if anyone, loses?
I suggest you begin with the conclusion so you can get a handle on what Tiebout is arguing AGAINST. From this section, as well as the introduction [esp 417-8] I think his point is to figure out if and how local governments [i.e. cities] can best meet the needs of their citizenry.
How does he define a public good? (417) What services qualify as a public good (418)?
How does he define a citizen-voter (418)?
Scrutinize the assumptions of his model: keep in mind his theory on citizen behavior:
What does he presume city residents do if they’re unhappy (420)?
What goal does he suggest cities aim to achieve? What does he suggest cities do if they are above/below/at their goal?
Does his analogy of the marketplace (421-2) seem workable to you? Does this model offer a reliable rendering of how
• Cities make taxing and spending decisions?
• People decide where to live?
For those of you who’d like a quick overview of his model, in this case I think wikipedia is a useful source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tiebout_model
Molotch
First of all pay particular attention to the title of this article. You should do this everytime you read a piece, as a good title is a window into someone’s analysis. In this case I think this is an exemplary title:
The City as a Growth Machine: Toward a Political Economy of Place.
What do we already know from this title? How does Molotch conceive of cities and the role of place in particular?
Right away Molotch cites Wirth, and argues that he omits “a crucial dimension of social structure: power and social class hierarchy” (309).
The next portion of the essay (310-8) describes the “growth machine”: who’s in the machine, who’s out of it? How does Molotch explain how land is used, how political coalitions are formed, how city government works and even what the function of city newspapers or universities is?
• Other questions include who participates in local politics and the role of “boosterism” (314)?
• What’s the importance of land values and speculation (317)?
Molotch next critiques the stated advantages of growth (318-25).
• What problems does growth produce?
• Who benefits from growth, and who pays?
• Why is the stated claim of job creation a lie? First understand Molotch’s argument (320), and then look at the evidence he uses to back up his case.
• Once you get his position, try to understand how he critiques Tiebout (bottom of 319) and Zorbaugh (325-6).
Last, how does he evaluate challenges to growth machines? For those of you familiar with Santa Barbara or other places that have fought growth, what consequences does it have for land, which is Molotch’s main concern?
When you’re done, take a step back and think about how Molotch sees cities’ ability to serve its residents: are cities democratic, can they be?
Oliver, The Rise of a Suburban Demos
Again I’ll give away the first level of reading—comprehension—for you. His main point is that “suburbs are bad for democracy.” Now that we have that out of the way, here are questions and comments to lead you deeper into the text.
After reading his introduction, what are his key research questions (4-5)?
• How does he distinguish his position from other authors who have argued a similar conclusion?
• What transformation does he argue takes place with suburbanization (5-7)? This is crucial to his overall argument.
How does he define a suburb (8-11)? Does this definition work for those of you who grew up in one?
What characteristics does Oliver say can distinguish suburbs from central cities, and each other? (12-15)?
• Why does he choose these, and what tradeoffs do they involve?
• Do you buy his analogy to a physician (14)?
Pay close attention to (15-17) where Oliver addresses both Tiebout and Molotch [partially in footnotes].
• How does he define democracy (18)?
• How does he measure “local civic activity” (19-21)? What does he omit?
• Crucially, how does he argue suburbs affect local participation (22-5)? Attempt a sketch of his model on (24-5).
• What data does he use—does it seem convincing for the argument he previews?
Last, and this argument should remind USP2 vets of Prof. Pezzoli’s emphasis on ‘regional governance,’ what real-world recommendations does Oliver offer based on his study?
Remember Oliver is offering an inherently ecological argument [that there is something particular to the form of suburbs that hurts democracy—what similarities or differences would you draw with Toonies/Wirth/Molotch?
Sunday, April 26, 2009
Saturday, April 18, 2009
Week 4 Reading Notes
WEEK 4
All of these readings deal with how people end up in certain areas of the city and not in others, and how to explain this pattern. Again the readings offer discernibly contradictory positions, so keep that in mind during your reading. Look for how these authors approach this question, and afterwards strive to set up your own view.
Zorbaugh
Take a minute to ponder the opening section: what does Zorbaugh mean when he says “The city is discovered to be an organization displaying certain typical processes of growth. Knowledge of these processes makes possible prediction of the direction, rate, and nature of its growth. That is, the city is found to be no an artifact but a natural phenomenon” (220-1)?
• Are we in control of our cities? He is implying here, especially through the examples of failed reform efforts, that cities have their own logic partially outside of our control.
• This is reflected in his theory of the “natural areas” of the city.
o Attempt to map out his model of the city as given on pp221-2. What are the main features of cities for Zorbaugh?
o What is the role of “impersonal competition” (222), land values, and segregation in creating distinctive “cultural areas” that match natural areas (222-3)?
o Reflect on the “plant ecology” metaphor (223). What does this analogy mean for his theory of urban development?
o Explain Zorbaugh’s notion of succession, as it is his theory of urban change.
• What are the consequences of the differences between natural and administrative areas of the city? Do you see this played out in San Diego?
Does Zorbaugh’s model of urban development make sense to you? Can it be used to explain San Diego, Los Angeles, or cities in the Bay Area?
Schelling
In this article Schelling outlines a number of MODELS of reality—motivated by actual histories of actual processes of racial change in neighborhoods [such as we read about blockbusting etc in USP1], and it is important to keep that distinction in mind. In order to create these models, the author makes many assumptions about reality—so if you disagree keep a running tally and save them for your critique. Still, articles like these are very interesting because they allow us to think about social processes by modeling them.
In particular, keep in mind Professor Martin’s point about Schelling having a contractual/marketplace view of racial discrimination as the result of a collection of individual decisions. That relates to his view of whether people are rational or irrational actors. But also keep in mind his views on social or individual ontology [i.e. which he thinks are real], and how he thinks order is achieved [i.e. consensus or conflict].
What kinds of evidence does he say we can use on this topic? If he had chosen the other kind of evidence, how would his analysis differ?
What is the definition of tipping? How might the notion of tipping differ if you looked at schools rather than neighborhoods [hint think about the difference between percentage and position]?
DON'T GET LOST IN THE MATH AND THE TECHNICAL LANGUAGE IN THE NEXT SECTION. KEEP THESE IN MIND: What does it mean for tipping to be a “threshold” or “continuous” phenomenon (159-65)? How do cities or neighborhoods differ based upon these different curves--i.e. different points at which neighborhoods tip?
What is a “crossover point” and why does it have important policy implications (166-8)?
What is the difference between tipping in and out?
173-83 Here the author returns to less formalistic, and more realistic/historical scenarios of tipping. Who are other actors involved in tipping, what are the effects of speculation and neighborhood composition, and what are possible non-racial forms of tipping?
Loic Wacquant
Wacquant offers a blistering critique of the kind of “natural” theory of how people come to live in certain areas rather than others. In his analysis of areas of “advanced marginality,” he focuses on notions of discourse, especially stigmatization, race, and space vs. place. As you read this article, keep in mind Professor Martin's point about Wacquant's emphasis on domination as explaining racial segregation. Where does this place him on the questions of action and social ontology?
What is the process by which areas of advanced marginality come to be stigmatized (67-8)?
Does it matter if the stories about these places are true? Why or why not?
What are the effects of such beliefs about these places
• On residents themselves (68)
• On policy makers with the power to affect social structures (69)?
Pp69-70. Here Wacquant argues paradoxically that even though areas of advanced marginality acquire incredibly strong and damaging reputations, they LOSE their sense of place.
• Describe the process by which these PLACES become SPACES.
• What are the consequences of this transition—make reference to his historical portrayal of how American black ghettoes have evolved (70).
Pp71-3. Finally, Wacquant offers a number of reasons why this problem is so difficult to address. Don’t get caught up with his use of “precariat”: it's a word he's made up to make a point. Keep in mind the contrast between whom he's calling the precariat, and the proletariat, or the working class. Marx predicted that the proletariat would be a political force--"workers of the world unite" was a famous line of his--predicting that workers would unite to topple capitalism and usher in communism. Wacquant's basic point, by contrast, is that these groups are fundamentally prevented from working together to improve their condition.
• Why do residents of marginal areas have so few resources [i.e. hinterland] to fall back upon?
• What is the importance of this group lacking “a language, a repertoire of shared images and signs” with which to describe itself (72)?
All of these readings deal with how people end up in certain areas of the city and not in others, and how to explain this pattern. Again the readings offer discernibly contradictory positions, so keep that in mind during your reading. Look for how these authors approach this question, and afterwards strive to set up your own view.
Zorbaugh
Take a minute to ponder the opening section: what does Zorbaugh mean when he says “The city is discovered to be an organization displaying certain typical processes of growth. Knowledge of these processes makes possible prediction of the direction, rate, and nature of its growth. That is, the city is found to be no an artifact but a natural phenomenon” (220-1)?
• Are we in control of our cities? He is implying here, especially through the examples of failed reform efforts, that cities have their own logic partially outside of our control.
• This is reflected in his theory of the “natural areas” of the city.
o Attempt to map out his model of the city as given on pp221-2. What are the main features of cities for Zorbaugh?
o What is the role of “impersonal competition” (222), land values, and segregation in creating distinctive “cultural areas” that match natural areas (222-3)?
o Reflect on the “plant ecology” metaphor (223). What does this analogy mean for his theory of urban development?
o Explain Zorbaugh’s notion of succession, as it is his theory of urban change.
• What are the consequences of the differences between natural and administrative areas of the city? Do you see this played out in San Diego?
Does Zorbaugh’s model of urban development make sense to you? Can it be used to explain San Diego, Los Angeles, or cities in the Bay Area?
Schelling
In this article Schelling outlines a number of MODELS of reality—motivated by actual histories of actual processes of racial change in neighborhoods [such as we read about blockbusting etc in USP1], and it is important to keep that distinction in mind. In order to create these models, the author makes many assumptions about reality—so if you disagree keep a running tally and save them for your critique. Still, articles like these are very interesting because they allow us to think about social processes by modeling them.
In particular, keep in mind Professor Martin’s point about Schelling having a contractual/marketplace view of racial discrimination as the result of a collection of individual decisions. That relates to his view of whether people are rational or irrational actors. But also keep in mind his views on social or individual ontology [i.e. which he thinks are real], and how he thinks order is achieved [i.e. consensus or conflict].
What kinds of evidence does he say we can use on this topic? If he had chosen the other kind of evidence, how would his analysis differ?
What is the definition of tipping? How might the notion of tipping differ if you looked at schools rather than neighborhoods [hint think about the difference between percentage and position]?
DON'T GET LOST IN THE MATH AND THE TECHNICAL LANGUAGE IN THE NEXT SECTION. KEEP THESE IN MIND: What does it mean for tipping to be a “threshold” or “continuous” phenomenon (159-65)? How do cities or neighborhoods differ based upon these different curves--i.e. different points at which neighborhoods tip?
What is a “crossover point” and why does it have important policy implications (166-8)?
What is the difference between tipping in and out?
173-83 Here the author returns to less formalistic, and more realistic/historical scenarios of tipping. Who are other actors involved in tipping, what are the effects of speculation and neighborhood composition, and what are possible non-racial forms of tipping?
Loic Wacquant
Wacquant offers a blistering critique of the kind of “natural” theory of how people come to live in certain areas rather than others. In his analysis of areas of “advanced marginality,” he focuses on notions of discourse, especially stigmatization, race, and space vs. place. As you read this article, keep in mind Professor Martin's point about Wacquant's emphasis on domination as explaining racial segregation. Where does this place him on the questions of action and social ontology?
What is the process by which areas of advanced marginality come to be stigmatized (67-8)?
Does it matter if the stories about these places are true? Why or why not?
What are the effects of such beliefs about these places
• On residents themselves (68)
• On policy makers with the power to affect social structures (69)?
Pp69-70. Here Wacquant argues paradoxically that even though areas of advanced marginality acquire incredibly strong and damaging reputations, they LOSE their sense of place.
• Describe the process by which these PLACES become SPACES.
• What are the consequences of this transition—make reference to his historical portrayal of how American black ghettoes have evolved (70).
Pp71-3. Finally, Wacquant offers a number of reasons why this problem is so difficult to address. Don’t get caught up with his use of “precariat”: it's a word he's made up to make a point. Keep in mind the contrast between whom he's calling the precariat, and the proletariat, or the working class. Marx predicted that the proletariat would be a political force--"workers of the world unite" was a famous line of his--predicting that workers would unite to topple capitalism and usher in communism. Wacquant's basic point, by contrast, is that these groups are fundamentally prevented from working together to improve their condition.
• Why do residents of marginal areas have so few resources [i.e. hinterland] to fall back upon?
• What is the importance of this group lacking “a language, a repertoire of shared images and signs” with which to describe itself (72)?
Sunday, April 12, 2009
Author Invite
Students:
Sorry for the delay, but I have invited you all to be authors of this blog. This is a way for those of you who do not like to speak in class to participate. That can take a variety of forms, including posting questions about readings, notes or thoughts about lectures or readings, and/or news items that remind you of class topics. Or anything else related to class.
I hope you're having a good weekend, and I'll see you tomorrow to discuss the Wirth essay.
Cheers
AC
Sorry for the delay, but I have invited you all to be authors of this blog. This is a way for those of you who do not like to speak in class to participate. That can take a variety of forms, including posting questions about readings, notes or thoughts about lectures or readings, and/or news items that remind you of class topics. Or anything else related to class.
I hope you're having a good weekend, and I'll see you tomorrow to discuss the Wirth essay.
Cheers
AC
Thursday, April 9, 2009
Add/Drop
Students:
At this point there are still 2 students who seek to add into our class.
If anyone is seriously considering dropping the class, please do so before midnight tonight so that they can be added to our class.
Even though tomorrow is the actual deadline, all drops must happen before tomorrow according to the way they wrote the online registration rules.
Thanks!
Andrew
At this point there are still 2 students who seek to add into our class.
If anyone is seriously considering dropping the class, please do so before midnight tonight so that they can be added to our class.
Even though tomorrow is the actual deadline, all drops must happen before tomorrow according to the way they wrote the online registration rules.
Thanks!
Andrew
Week 3 Reading Notes
Students:
Again there was great discussion in lecture yesterday regarding Simmel, keep it up. I just got the list of email addresses from Valorie, so you'll be added as an author of this blog soon. At that point, you can post here.
I know this is looking ahead, but here are your reading notes for Week 3. Remember we will be discussing Wirth on Monday in section.
Cheers,
Andrew
WEEK 3
Again Professor Martin has chosen our week’s readings so that we can understand a particular debate, with the authors taking clearly contrasting positions. Wirth’s essay strongly influenced Gans’ response, and Fischer’s theory responds to both. If last week we read two authors who argued for different theories of human action in cities, this week we are reading three contrasting positions on IF, and HOW, cities produce particular cultures.
Wirth
What empirical changes in the real world prompt his inquiry into the “urban mode of living” (1-3)?
Foremost, what is his “sociological definition of the city” (4-8)?
• What are the three key components of this definition?
• How does this definition seek to be flexible to describe most, if not all cities, rather than just a few, or a certain kind of city?
Once you understand his definition, then focus upon how Wirth argues these 3 features affect city life (10-18)?
• I suggest you write up a small table, and keep a list of the effects that Wirth sees each city feature having on urban culture.
• Do you see parallels to Tonnies, Le Bon, or Simmel in this section?
Finally, how does Wirth argue cities affect “social organization” (20-4)?
• What ties are forged, and which ties erode under urban conditions?
• What types of activities do urban individuals pursue, and what groups do they form?
Gans’ essay is in direct response to Wirth’s, and challenges many of his conclusions.
What 2 areas of cities does he focus on? How do the empirical trends in these places relate to his revision of Wirth? (171)
What reasons does he offer for challenging Wirth’s conclusion that cities create particular cultures (172-5)?
• What are the 5 types of people who live in inner cities, and what alternatives to Wirth’s explanation does Gans offer for their behavior (175-6)
What are quasi-primary relationships? How does Gans argue these are different than the kinds of relationships Wirth saw as created by cities (177-8)?
What do you make of his position that suburbs are essentially indistinguishable from cities (178-82)?
Fischer
Fischer’s essay is an interesting counterpoint to Wirth and Gans because he argues partially against both. He disagrees with Gans by arguing that cities DO create particular cultures [subcultures] but disagrees with Wirth by offering different mechanisms by which cities create subcultures [i.e. focus on the Implications section for this 1336-7].
What is a subculture (1323)?
What are the mechanisms by which Fischer sees cities creating subcultures? [Hint, the first two are in Proposition 2 and the third is Proposition 3. Why he isn’t better organized is beyond me.]
*Look for similarities to Simmel in Fischer's argument here.
Having read all three pieces, now think for yourself: do you agree or disagree that there is something inherent about cities that produces particular cultures, or ways of living? Why or why not? And if you do agree, do you think that Wirth or Fischer have it right about the mechanisms by which cities create cultures? Or do you see other forces at work?
Again there was great discussion in lecture yesterday regarding Simmel, keep it up. I just got the list of email addresses from Valorie, so you'll be added as an author of this blog soon. At that point, you can post here.
I know this is looking ahead, but here are your reading notes for Week 3. Remember we will be discussing Wirth on Monday in section.
Cheers,
Andrew
WEEK 3
Again Professor Martin has chosen our week’s readings so that we can understand a particular debate, with the authors taking clearly contrasting positions. Wirth’s essay strongly influenced Gans’ response, and Fischer’s theory responds to both. If last week we read two authors who argued for different theories of human action in cities, this week we are reading three contrasting positions on IF, and HOW, cities produce particular cultures.
Wirth
What empirical changes in the real world prompt his inquiry into the “urban mode of living” (1-3)?
Foremost, what is his “sociological definition of the city” (4-8)?
• What are the three key components of this definition?
• How does this definition seek to be flexible to describe most, if not all cities, rather than just a few, or a certain kind of city?
Once you understand his definition, then focus upon how Wirth argues these 3 features affect city life (10-18)?
• I suggest you write up a small table, and keep a list of the effects that Wirth sees each city feature having on urban culture.
• Do you see parallels to Tonnies, Le Bon, or Simmel in this section?
Finally, how does Wirth argue cities affect “social organization” (20-4)?
• What ties are forged, and which ties erode under urban conditions?
• What types of activities do urban individuals pursue, and what groups do they form?
Gans’ essay is in direct response to Wirth’s, and challenges many of his conclusions.
What 2 areas of cities does he focus on? How do the empirical trends in these places relate to his revision of Wirth? (171)
What reasons does he offer for challenging Wirth’s conclusion that cities create particular cultures (172-5)?
• What are the 5 types of people who live in inner cities, and what alternatives to Wirth’s explanation does Gans offer for their behavior (175-6)
What are quasi-primary relationships? How does Gans argue these are different than the kinds of relationships Wirth saw as created by cities (177-8)?
What do you make of his position that suburbs are essentially indistinguishable from cities (178-82)?
Fischer
Fischer’s essay is an interesting counterpoint to Wirth and Gans because he argues partially against both. He disagrees with Gans by arguing that cities DO create particular cultures [subcultures] but disagrees with Wirth by offering different mechanisms by which cities create subcultures [i.e. focus on the Implications section for this 1336-7].
What is a subculture (1323)?
What are the mechanisms by which Fischer sees cities creating subcultures? [Hint, the first two are in Proposition 2 and the third is Proposition 3. Why he isn’t better organized is beyond me.]
*Look for similarities to Simmel in Fischer's argument here.
Having read all three pieces, now think for yourself: do you agree or disagree that there is something inherent about cities that produces particular cultures, or ways of living? Why or why not? And if you do agree, do you think that Wirth or Fischer have it right about the mechanisms by which cities create cultures? Or do you see other forces at work?
Wednesday, April 8, 2009
Limits of Le Bon?
Students:
As I suggested in section Monday, I have my doubts about Le Bon's theory. He has some good points about what happens IN a crowd, but
-why do crowds form?
-when might crowds form or disperse?
-what's the role of leaders? [he does address this at times, but not much]
-in our age, what's the role of technology?
I was happy with the level of engagement you had with the text, so here's an article for those of you who are interested on the topic in our context from today's NY Times.
MOSCOW — A crowd of more than 10,000 young Moldovans materialized seemingly out of nowhere on Tuesday to protest against Moldova’s Communist leadership, ransacking government buildings and clashing with the police.
Also, I contacted the USP office and should have you all updated as authors for the blog soon.
Again, look here toward the end of every week for reading notes on the upcoming week's articles. So, toward the end of this week I'll post notes on Week 3's readings.
-AC
As I suggested in section Monday, I have my doubts about Le Bon's theory. He has some good points about what happens IN a crowd, but
-why do crowds form?
-when might crowds form or disperse?
-what's the role of leaders? [he does address this at times, but not much]
-in our age, what's the role of technology?
I was happy with the level of engagement you had with the text, so here's an article for those of you who are interested on the topic in our context from today's NY Times.
Protests in Moldova Explode, With Help of Twitter
MOSCOW — A crowd of more than 10,000 young Moldovans materialized seemingly out of nowhere on Tuesday to protest against Moldova’s Communist leadership, ransacking government buildings and clashing with the police.
The sea of young people reflected the deep generation gap that has developed in Moldova, and the protesters used their generation’s tools, gathering the crowd by enlisting text-messaging, Facebook and Twitter, the social messaging network.
The protesters created their own searchable tag on Twitter, rallying Moldovans to join and propelling events in this small former Soviet state onto a Twitter list of newly popular topics, so people around the world could keep track.
By Tuesday night, the seat of government had been badly battered and scores of people had been injured. But riot police had regained control of the president’s offices and Parliament Wednesday.
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/08/world/europe/08moldova.htmlAlso, I contacted the USP office and should have you all updated as authors for the blog soon.
Again, look here toward the end of every week for reading notes on the upcoming week's articles. So, toward the end of this week I'll post notes on Week 3's readings.
-AC
Monday, April 6, 2009
PARTIAL OFFICE HOURS TODAY
Students:
I have an appointment that just came up and will only be at office hours from 2-2:30 today. If people need to meet with me this week, please email me for an appointment.
I'll see you in section,
Andrew
I have an appointment that just came up and will only be at office hours from 2-2:30 today. If people need to meet with me this week, please email me for an appointment.
I'll see you in section,
Andrew
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)